Broke my tailwheel spring :-{
- Tralika
- Veteran Member
- Posts: 386
- Joined: Thu Oct 08, 2009 12:49 pm
- Location: Wasilla Alaska
Re: Broke my tailwheel spring :-{
Did anyone contact Atlas Suspension http://www.atlassuspension.com/ about making a replacement Highlander tail wheel spring?
John Nealon
Wasilla, Alaska
Highlander Extreme #191
mykitlog.com/jnealon
Wasilla, Alaska
Highlander Extreme #191
mykitlog.com/jnealon
- alan
- Veteran Member
- Posts: 398
- Joined: Fri Feb 04, 2005 1:39 am
- Location: Baytown, TX
Re: Broke my tailwheel spring :-{
OK, here is the final update. We got a certified welder to add the plates and gussets I made. That worked out really well, as you can see from the pictures. He used MIG and welding inside and out. Very nice work. After all the painting and recovering I thought it was all done. There were several wait periods because of hardware issues but Aircraft Spruce helped us out there. Then, when all was ready, the tailwheel wouldn't unlock. It is a Maule tailwheel and works really well. It seems that during the "incident", when the tailwheel was being ripped off, the unlock pin was damaged. That was another 4 days of waiting. Today, after 7-1/12 weeks of working and waiting, N1010Z aced her taxi test and flight. Yeehaa! Back in the air again. Check out the photos.
Apparently I'm not very good with attaching pictures as the order is kind of strange, but it's all done. Thanks for all the advice.
Alan
Apparently I'm not very good with attaching pictures as the order is kind of strange, but it's all done. Thanks for all the advice.
Alan
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.
If I had known I would live this long I would have taken better care of myself.
- Gil T
- Veteran Member
- Posts: 162
- Joined: Thu Jun 03, 2010 10:57 pm
- Location: Quartzsite AZ
Re: Broke my tailwheel spring :-{
Alan
That looks like a lot of iron added to the back. Do you have any drawings of the pieces? It looks like it should be in a kit readily available labeled "For Those Who Land In Interesting Places Or Have Twitchy Tail Wheels". This seems to happen often enough with the Highlander that we shouldn't have to reinvent the process every time it happens. How much weight did it add? It does look like a nice installation.
Gil T
That looks like a lot of iron added to the back. Do you have any drawings of the pieces? It looks like it should be in a kit readily available labeled "For Those Who Land In Interesting Places Or Have Twitchy Tail Wheels". This seems to happen often enough with the Highlander that we shouldn't have to reinvent the process every time it happens. How much weight did it add? It does look like a nice installation.
Gil T
- alan
- Veteran Member
- Posts: 398
- Joined: Fri Feb 04, 2005 1:39 am
- Location: Baytown, TX
Re: Broke my tailwheel spring :-{
Thank you Gil. The pieces are .090 for the two bottom ones and .050 for the sides. Not including the weld wire these parts are almost 2#. There is no kit because no one could afford my labor rate.
If I had known I would live this long I would have taken better care of myself.
-
- Veteran Member
- Posts: 494
- Joined: Sat May 17, 2008 12:34 am
- Location: Nampa Idaho
Re: Broke my tailwheel spring :-{
I land in some very rocky rough places often and if I did normal three point landings I would probably be breaking my tail wheel off on a regular basis, so therefore I don't do regular three-point landings in my Highlander. I do my approach as if I am going to do a slow as possible three-point landing but at the very last second I make it into a short wheel landing. I'm usually hanging it on the prop a little and at the last moment I drop the flaps and cut the power and set it on the mains. It does take a little practice but it sure does work well for saving your tail wheel and also for seeing over the nose when I'm landing in weird places.
I nearly always three-point my Superstol, in fact the tail will almost always hit first before the mains. Because of the shock absorber system on the SuperSTOL it is not abusive to the tail a like three-point landing a Highlander is when landing in very rough terrain. Probably the biggest thing for taking care of the tail end of a Highlander for pilots landing in more ordinary places is making sure you never have tail wheel shimmy.
I nearly always three-point my Superstol, in fact the tail will almost always hit first before the mains. Because of the shock absorber system on the SuperSTOL it is not abusive to the tail a like three-point landing a Highlander is when landing in very rough terrain. Probably the biggest thing for taking care of the tail end of a Highlander for pilots landing in more ordinary places is making sure you never have tail wheel shimmy.
Steve Henry, Wild West Aircraft
(the Dead Stick Take-off Guy)
(the Dead Stick Take-off Guy)
- alan
- Veteran Member
- Posts: 398
- Joined: Fri Feb 04, 2005 1:39 am
- Location: Baytown, TX
Re: Broke my tailwheel spring :-{
Hi Steve.
That's a good tip about the short wheel landing. My tailwheel had shimmied maybe 4 times before that. I should have investigated it better but for some reason I thought the shimmy was the tailwheel being out of alignment with the rudder because my homefield always has a crosswind. In hindsight this was not a good thought. I always have to make a memorable mistake or two before I really learn something.
As an addendum to my last "last update" post, here is another update.
When I was about to do the test taxi/flight I found the Maule tailwheel wouldn't unlock. To make a long story quite short, the lockpin had lost its' actuator pin. See the attacked pics. After another 4 day wait for 2nd day air from AC Spruce, all is now well.
Alan
That's a good tip about the short wheel landing. My tailwheel had shimmied maybe 4 times before that. I should have investigated it better but for some reason I thought the shimmy was the tailwheel being out of alignment with the rudder because my homefield always has a crosswind. In hindsight this was not a good thought. I always have to make a memorable mistake or two before I really learn something.
As an addendum to my last "last update" post, here is another update.
When I was about to do the test taxi/flight I found the Maule tailwheel wouldn't unlock. To make a long story quite short, the lockpin had lost its' actuator pin. See the attacked pics. After another 4 day wait for 2nd day air from AC Spruce, all is now well.
Alan
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.
If I had known I would live this long I would have taken better care of myself.
-
- Veteran Member
- Posts: 480
- Joined: Thu May 12, 2011 5:01 pm
Re: Broke my tailwheel spring :-{
I'm really surprised that no one has made a fibreglass tail spring for our Highlanders yet? Or maybe some sort of a metal rod like they use on a Cessna 180/185. The single metal spring is just asking for trouble in my opinion. And all that flex and vibration from that single spring moving so much is bound to put a lot of stress on the fuselage where the spring attaches.
I seem to recall the iron design tailwheel used a nice round rod for a spring. Not sure how that worked out overall, but I like that concept best.
I seem to recall the iron design tailwheel used a nice round rod for a spring. Not sure how that worked out overall, but I like that concept best.
- SheepdogRD
- Proprietor
- Posts: 933
- Joined: Tue Nov 30, 2010 5:41 pm
- Location: West of Atlanta, GA
Re: Broke my tailwheel spring :-{
All the spring-type systems concentrate the stresses in a small area right at the end of the fuselage. After reading about incidents of broken tailsprings and shimmying and the resulting damage, I decided to convert our Highlander to the shock absorber tailwheel system used on the SuperSTOL. It damps the vibrations and spreads the loads over a much longer and wider area.
Using the shock absorber system does require that additional mounts are welded in place, but the welding required isn't as extensive as Alan's solution. Here are pictures of Highlander and SuperSTOL tail sections showing the differences:
On the cluster in the lower left, the curved tubes and pivot mounts are welded in. On the cluster in the upper right, pivot mounts and some supporting plates are added.
Our conversion was made just before covering the fuselage, using a "kit" developed at the factory when they were converting Highlanders to SuperSTOLs. The factory uses a fixture for the installation, but field installations can be done using the system components for alignment.
If I were ordering a Highlander now, I'd request that those shock mounts be installed when the fuselage is built.
Here's a picture of the airshock tailwheel kit components that may help clarify how the system works.
The arm on the left pivots at the front mount. The top of the shock is bolted to the upper mount in the fuselage, and the bottom is bolted between the eyeplates welded to the arm.
The aluminum "stinger" bolts into the end of the arm.
Builders can choose to complete the system with a standard tailwheel by using the adapter seen next to the arm, or they can use a stinger-mount tailwheel that eliminates the adapter.
Using the shock absorber system does require that additional mounts are welded in place, but the welding required isn't as extensive as Alan's solution. Here are pictures of Highlander and SuperSTOL tail sections showing the differences:
On the cluster in the lower left, the curved tubes and pivot mounts are welded in. On the cluster in the upper right, pivot mounts and some supporting plates are added.
Our conversion was made just before covering the fuselage, using a "kit" developed at the factory when they were converting Highlanders to SuperSTOLs. The factory uses a fixture for the installation, but field installations can be done using the system components for alignment.
If I were ordering a Highlander now, I'd request that those shock mounts be installed when the fuselage is built.
Here's a picture of the airshock tailwheel kit components that may help clarify how the system works.
The arm on the left pivots at the front mount. The top of the shock is bolted to the upper mount in the fuselage, and the bottom is bolted between the eyeplates welded to the arm.
The aluminum "stinger" bolts into the end of the arm.
Builders can choose to complete the system with a standard tailwheel by using the adapter seen next to the arm, or they can use a stinger-mount tailwheel that eliminates the adapter.
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.
Richard Holtz
Highlander N570L -- Ms. Tonka -- in gestation
If just enough is really good, then too much ought to be perfect.
Highlander N570L -- Ms. Tonka -- in gestation
If just enough is really good, then too much ought to be perfect.
- danerazz
- Veteran Member
- Posts: 1240
- Joined: Tue Aug 18, 2009 9:33 pm
- Location: Bangor
Re: Broke my tailwheel spring :-{
I have an iron-design TW and stinger rod spring. I obviously have not flown with it, but have heard good reports. There are several on here that can report better than me, but at least it looks good!
Dane
Paralysis by analysis
#242
Paralysis by analysis
#242
-
- Veteran Member
- Posts: 112
- Joined: Fri Jun 01, 2012 10:18 am
- Location: Bangkok, Thailand
Re: Broke my tailwheel spring :-{
Iron Design stinger tailwheel is junk.
I don't have to be a rocket scientist to figure out that a stainless steel rod bolted to a piece of steel offers you ZERO flex, and metal fatigue at the attaching point.
It might be good if you never land on anything but paved runway, but it rode like crap elsewhere. The design offers no built in shock absorption.
150% improvement putting on an Outcast tailwheel. That huge cushy tire on the back might solve some peoples tailwheel spring issues.
I don't have to be a rocket scientist to figure out that a stainless steel rod bolted to a piece of steel offers you ZERO flex, and metal fatigue at the attaching point.
It might be good if you never land on anything but paved runway, but it rode like crap elsewhere. The design offers no built in shock absorption.
150% improvement putting on an Outcast tailwheel. That huge cushy tire on the back might solve some peoples tailwheel spring issues.